To be considered as a Club Legend, a nominee must meet at least one of the following criteria and be endorsed by signature, by two current playing members or life members:

Criteria 1: Played at least 200 games for Burnside or played as a senior for at least 15 years.

Criteria 2: Have represented a country, state, or RUSA team, won a Don Smith medal or another RUSA award, and have played at Burnside for at least 100 games or 10 years.

Only two Club Legends can be appointed each year.

The following table contains all BRUFC Legend inductees to date.

Brian Alexander	Doug Turner	Alan Bailey
Peter Baker	Fred Bevan	John Bradley
Clyde Buttery	Michael Deacon	Matt Delaney
Michael De Vizio	John Difilipo	Jim Dowe
Robert Gray	Alasdair Hamilton	Michael Henry
Michael Hocking	John Nation	Mark Roderick
Colin Rutledge	Ron Sewer	John Stankovich
	Reuben Nation	Kathryn Van Diemen
Peter Wilson	Patrick Betham	Ross Butcher
Huw Davies	Owen Davies	Lee Fata
Tim Lough	Mike Meredith	Catherine Arnfield
Keu Paitai	Wayne Vincent	Richmond Tuhou
Rebecca Smith	Eugene Lagana	Paul Stevenson
Leigh Cunnington	Chris Walton